Looking for a perfume similar to Abercrombie Fitch First Instinct Extreme? Below are 12 fragrances from our database of 24,000+ designer and niche scents that share its musky, fresh spicy, warm spicy profile with prominent carambola (star fruit), pepper, mandarin leaf notes. We score similarity by shared accords and notes — rare ingredients count more than common ones — so the matches you see are the ones that genuinely smell closest.